Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player

 
 

 

Home


Welcome to this site. My name is David Mckiernan.


I have spent sixteen years performing cosmetic and functional nasal surgery and remain fascinated by this rapidly changing sub-specialisation. I hope that what follows will give you some insight into recent developments in this area and the subtleties of nasal surgery. There can be no substitute for face to face contact with your surgeon but I hope you gain some indication of what can be realistically achieved and a flavour of my practice. In line with General Medical Council guidance there are no clinical photographs on this site.

Your surgeon




I am a teaching hospital Consultant who specialises in all aspects of nasal and facial
plastic surgery. My practice encompasses primary and revision aesthetic rhinoplasty,
endoscopic sinus surgery, the management of nasal malignancies and the medical
management of nasal problems. I graduated in Medicine from the University of
London in 1989 and subsequently became a Fellow of the Royal College of Surgeons
of England
and pursued Higher Surgical Training leading to accreditation. I was
awarded a European Academy of Facial Plastic Surgery Fellowship, enabling me to
pursue advanced training in Germany, France and the United States. After passing
the American Academy of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery's exam I was
certified in facial plastic surgery by the European Academy. I have published articles
and papers on facial plastic and head and neck surgery and am a Consultant
Surgeon to Addenbrookes and the West Suffolk Hospitals NHS Trusts. I am
married with two children.



Rhinoplasty

What is a rhinoplasty?


Rhinoplasty is the generic term for an operation to re-shape the nose - in common parlance "a nose job". When combined with a procedure to straighten the septum and restore the nasal airway the procedure is described as a "septorhinoplasty".

Why have a rhinoplasty?


Concerns regarding nasal appearance (such as a large nose, poor nasal profile or ill defined tip) can be addressed by rhinoplasty techniques. Equally factors which compromise the nasal airway (such as deviation of the nasal septum, drooping of the nasal tip or a tendency for the nostrils to collapse on deep inspiration) can be corrected. Very often functional and cosmetic problems will co-exist.

What's new in rhinoplasty surgery?


We now have a better understanding of the structural supports of the nose and how the final result slowly evolves over a period of months as the delicate nasal tissues heal. Over-resection of tissues to give an immediate impact will eventually give an unnatural appearance and often causes functional problems as well. My philosophy is to maintain structural integrity and to give a natural unoperated appearance in harmony with the rest of the face. The use of digital-image-manipulation software is used to demonstrate the likely outcome of surgery.



What can be done?


Rhinoplasty is sometimes erroneously compared with sculpture. In fact it's more like pitching a tent! Great care has to be taken to address the underlying structural elements so that the skin and soft tissues will redrape appropriately. Clearly the size, shape and consistency of the underlying bony and cartilaginous structural elements and the quality and thickness of the skin do impose limitations on what can be achieved and these will be discussed at your consultation. Nonetheless it is generally possible to:

  • straighten the nose and improve the nasal profile (either by removing a hump or by filling depressions with sculpted cartilage harvested from within the nose)
  • improve the size and shape of the nasal tip and its relation to the rest of the nose
  • adjust nasal breadth to achieve a more harmonius appearance
  • alter nasal length
  • improve the nasal airway

Is cosmetic rhinoplasty right for me?


This is clearly a very personal matter. If you have a particular deformity which is impacting on your self confidence or you have difficulty breathing through your nose it is highly likely that skillfully performed surgery can help. This is something that I will be very happy to discuss.

What happens during a consultation?


After establishing exactly what your concerns are and taking a comprehensive medical history I will want to examine your nose to correlate those concerns with the underlying anatomy. This may include an examination of the inside of your nose and an assessment of the airway and tip support. This is extremely important because factors such as skin type and nasal airway do influence the techniques which should be employed. I will then discuss any surgery that I think might be necessary with you and demonstrate what I think can be achieved using the latest digital image manipulation software. I am very fortunate in having a large number of patients who are happy for their pre and post-operative images to be shown. This means that you can see the actual results achieved for patients with similar concerns to your own.

Do I need a letter from my GP?

This is not absolutely necessary but I like to work closely with your doctor and providing you are agreeable will write to them after the consultation.

How much will it cost?


If your concerns are purely cosmetic you will be invoiced a nominal fee. However if there is a functional problem or you have recently suffered nasal trauma your medical insurance will cover your outpatient consultation. If surgery is required a written quotation will be sent to you , based on your individual treatment needs. In most cases we can offer a "Fixed Cost Care" fully inclusive package price for your operation and hospital stay. If you have any concerns please feel free to ask.

Why do I decline to treat certain patients?


I have a very busy practice and receive a lot of referrals from colleagues. Experience has taught me that a superlative technical outcome alone does not guarantee patient satisfaction. A successful outcome is much more likely when patient expectations and my assessment of the likely outcome of surgery coincide. Digital-image-manipulation software has greatly aided these discussions. As this is elective surgery patients are also declined when serious co-existing medical conditions make general anaesthesia hazardous.

If surgery is required how long will I need to take off work?


You will generally spend one night in hospital following a rhinoplasty because of the possibility of bleeding. The surgery is not painful but you will feel blocked up (like with a cold) for a week to ten days and your nose will run. There will also be some bruising beneath the eyes which can be camouflaged with makeup. If your job is physically demanding you will require two weeks off but if you wanted you would be able to do paperwork after two or three days.

What about packs and splints?


With meticulous technique nasal packing is generally not required although you will have a light dressing at the front of the nose which is removed when you are awake and a nasal splint which maintains the position of the nasal bones and is left on for a week.

And follow-up?


I will review you at one week to remove the nasal splint. In most cases I will see you again two months later and one year after surgery. If you have any concerns additional appointments will be made.

 

Endoscopic Sinus Surgery

 

When medical management fails to resolve infection or nasal polyposis, surgery is indicated. This has been revolutionised in recent years by:

  • An improved understanding of the natural drainage passageways from the sinuses. Previously surgery took no account of this. We aim to restore natural sinus anatomy and functioning.
  • Better imaging techniques including CT and MRI scans allow for a precise diagnosis of the problem.
  • Improved instrumentation allows for focused surgery with less post-operative bleeding and usually no need for nasal packing.
  • Balloon sinuplasty

What is an endoscope?


This instrument ( developed at Reading University by Professor Hopkin ) has transformed nasal surgery. It provides an unsurpassed view of the nasal cavity and paranasal sinuses drainage pathways. The picture below on the right shows the magnified view it provides of pus in the right middle meatus (sinus drainage passageway). Prior to the introduction of endoscopes the nose could only be examined with a headlight. Rather than enlarging the natural drainage passageways, unnatural drainage holes were fashioned and mucosa was stripped.



What other instruments have transformed sinus surgery and why?

Basic research by Messerklinger confirmed the importance of healthy mucosa to the normal functioning of the nose. This heralded a change in philosophy away from "stripping" mucosa towards "through-cutting" and mucosal preservation. The two video clips below show the use of instruments which precisely resect mucosa. This means that post-operatively the nasal cavity is lined by healthy mucous membrane rather than having exposed bone over which scar tissue forms.



Why are CT scans necessary?


Although the CT scan opposite beautifully demonstrates sinus anatomy
they are not usually required for diagnostic purposes. They are
however necessary to prevent complications. Because sinus anatomy
varies significantly between individuals the scans are necessary to
delineate the anatomy of the paranasal sinuses and their relationship
to adjacent structures such as the anterior skull base, optic nerve and
internal carotid artery.



What are the risks of sinus surgery?


All operations carry risk and endoscopic sinus surgery is no different. The risks are identical to
those of simple polypectomy but arguably (because of the better view afforded by the
endoscope and the anatomical information provided by the CT scan) much less likely to occur.
The problems which have been reported in the literature arise because of damage to adjacent
structures. The CT scan below shows the proximity of the nasal sinuses to the orbit and anterior
skull base. Further back the sinuses are related to the optic nerve and internal carotid artery.
Damage to these structures would clearly lead to serious complications. For example breach
of the skull base would cause a leak of cerebrospinal fluid ( which bathes the brain ) into the
nose. This might result in meningitis. Mr Mckiernan has never personally caused such a
complication but has experience of managing them. This all serves to underline the
importance of training and subspecialisation.

Is endoscopic sinus surgery conventional surgery with an endoscope?


No. The philosophy of FESS (functional endoscopic sinus surgery) is to preserve healthy nasal mucosa and restore normal anatomy and functioning. Older style operations deal with those parts of the nose which are readily accessible with a headlight. So, for example, in order to drain the cheek sinus a new opening would be fashioned low down in the nose instead of enlarging the natural drainage passageway. Of course the nasal secretions still move towards the natural opening which remains blocked! In FESS the natural drainage passageway would be enlarged.

How successful is it?


Research has confirmed that endoscopic sinus surgery is successful in treating nasal polyps, facial pain caused by sinus disease and sinus infections although there is a rendency for polyps to recur and maintenance therapy will be required. It may also help with snoring and improve your sense of taste and smell. What we call "postnasal drip" is not well addressed by this or any other surgery. There are however a variety of medical treatments which might help.

The extended role of endoscopic sinus surgery


Increasingly conventional "open approaches" to the nose and adjacent structures are being superceded by minimally invasive endoscopic approaches. These can be used in:

  • tear duct and lacrimal sac surgery ("endoscopic dacrocystorhinostomy" or "DCR")
  • frontal sinus surgery
  • repair of CSF leaks
  • cosmetic surgery for prominent eyes often associated with thyroid disease ("orbital decompression")
  • Arterial clipping to control nosebleeds ("sphenopalatine artery ligation")

I perform all of the above operations in addition to "open approaches" where indicated

 

Septoplasty

What is the nasal septum?


The nasal septum is the structure which divides the nasal cavity into two. It comprises cartilage at the front and bone higher up and further back and is covered on both sides with nasal mucosa.



Why should surgery be necessary?


Deviation of the nasal septum not only compromises the nasal airway but can also predispose to sinusitis where there is contact between it and the outer nasal wall. At points of contact the microscopic "cilia" which clear nasal secretions stop working and infection can develop.

Deviation of the septum can also result in deviation of the nasal tip and correction of the septum is therefore necessary to straighten the nose.

Occasionally a defect in the septum can result in collapse of the nasal dorsum and a "saddle" like appearance. This can be caused by a variety of medical conditions and nasal trauma but unfortunately is most often seen after surgery where the nasal mucosa has not been preserved and the underlying cartilage, deprived of nutrition from the mucosa "melts away" to leave a septal perforation. Cocaine abuse has the same effect. Septal perforations can also cause an audible whistle, bleeding and crusting.

What surgery is performed?


Surgery to reposition a deviated nasal septum is known as a septoplasty. This is performed under general anaesthetic through small incisions within the nose.

Septal reconstruction using cartilage harvested from the ear and mucosal flaps to cover the graft occasionally requires an "open" approach with a small incision crossing the skin between the nostrils. This incision tends to heal extremely well and is generally barely perceptible after a few weeks.

What's new?


  • Endoscopic septoplasty allows a minimally invasive approach
  • Suturing septum to avoid nasal packing
  • Emphasis on cartilage preservation and meticulous care with mucosa to prevent perforation
  • Biomaterials in septal reconstruction

 

Surgery for nasal obstruction

What is nasal obstruction?


This is an inability to breath through the nose.

What are the causes?


Nasal obstruction can be caused by deformities of the nasal skeleton or inflammation of the nasal lining.

How can it be treated?


Treatment depends on the underlying cause:

  • Twists or buckling of the nasal septum ( the partition which divides the nasal cavity into two) require septoplasty
  • Drooping of the nasal tip, a tendency for the nostrils to collapse on inspiration or a narrow nose are amenable to rhinoplasty
  • Inflammation of the nasal lining (rhinits) with or without nasal polyps can be treated with medication but if this fails endoscopic sinus surgery may be required

Skin Cancer

Is skin cancer common?


Although there are are no reliable national UK figures, studies from overseas suggest the incidence of skin cancer is rising. In the United States there are over 500 000 new cases each year, with 80% occuring in the head and neck. The overwhelming majority involve the nose and ear.

What are the different types?


The three commonest forms of skin cancer are basal cell carcinoma, squamous cell carcinoma and malignant melanoma. Basal cell carcinoma accounts for over 80% of cases.

  Basal cell carcinoma - there are different forms. This one has the characteristic "pearly nodule" appearance
Squamous cell carcinoma - these often present as a sore that does not heal
Malignant melanoma - these are often asymetrical with blurred edges. Just to complicate matters they are not always pigmented.


 

How are they treated?


Local anaesthetic day-surgical excision is the mainstay of treatment although basal cell and squamous cell carcinomas are also responsive to radiotherapy. If caught early the majority will be cured. Patients with malignant melanoma may require additional treatment. It is important that your surgeon should have excellent working relationships with colleagues who will be involved in this care ( dermatologists, radiotherapists and oncologists, radiologists and histopathologists) I participate in the regional MDT (multi-disciplinary team) in dermatopathology where the management of individual cases is reviewed.

Are there any special considerations with skin cancer involving the nose?


Excision of skin lesions on the nose with adequate margins to prevent recurrence will leave defects which cannot be simply ("primarily ") closed without distorting the nose itself or adjacent areas such as the eyelids. There are a multitude of local flaps which can be used to transfer skin to fill the "gap". These should be carefully planned and executed to achieve the optimum cosmetic result. Superspecialisation and a familiarity with a range of alternative options to close any defect created will avoid compromise on the excision margins to facilitate surgical repair.

Where a full thickness defect is created it is important that that the underlying bony and cartilaginous framework of the nose and internal mucosal lining are reconstructed. Simply filling the defect with a mass of skin will lead to a poor cosmetic and functional result. Without cartilaginous support and an internal lining the skin flap will simply contract.

It is vitally important that any extension of cutaneous malignancy into the nasal cavity and sinuses is adequately resected. This is dependent on adequate pre-operative radiological and endoscopic assessment.

What can I do to avoid getting it in the first place?


To reduce your risk of cancer:

  • stop smoking
  • avoid sunburn especially in childhood
  • wear a broad rimmed hat in the sun and use a sunscreen

...and other lesions?


Similar techniques can be used to remove disfiguring non-malignant lesions from the nose. Surgical and laser techniques also exist to address scarring.



The Nose Clinic

Who can be seen in the specialist nose clinic?


Anyone with a nose problem. This may include:

  • People who have problems breathing through their nose
  • People who are concerned about the appearance of their nose
  • People with sinus problems
  • Snorers
  • People with allergic problems
  • People who are worried about cancer

Why a specialist nose clinic?


Nasal problems affect a large proportion of the population, with a dramatic impact on quality of life. Recent technological advances and a better understanding of the underlying anatomy and physiology mean that there is much more that can now be done to help. The Nose Clinic is staffed by specialists who concentrate on nasal problems. If you have a longstanding nasal problem but thought there was little that could be done we would be pleased to help.

What advances have there been in the treatment of nasal problems?


Lots of nasal problems can be successfully treated with medication.

Sometimes surgery is necessary:

Nasal surgery to address airway and sinus problems has been revolutionised by :

  • An improved understanding of the natural drainage passageways from the sinuses. Previously surgery took no account of this. We aim to restore natural sinus anatomy and functioning.
  • Better imaging techniques including CT and MRI scans allow for a precise diagnosis of the problem.
  • Improved instrumentation allows for focused surgery with less post-operative bleeding and usually no need for nasal packing.

Surgery to address the appearance of the nose has benefited from:

  • Digital imaging and image manipulation software to enhance pre-operative analysis of the underlying structural problem. This allows us to show you the likely outcome of any surgery.
  • A better understanding of the variations in nasal anatomy and the structural supports of the nose

 

Your Consultant


The nose clinic is run by Mr David Mckiernan FRCS, a teaching hospital consultant. He has extensive experience of performing minimally invasive (endoscopic) sinus surgery and nasal plastic surgery. As well as being a member of the British Association of Otorhinolaryngologists - Head & Neck Surgeons, he is a member of the British Rhinological Society and a Diplomate of the American Academy of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery.

What will happen?


You will be greeted in the clinic and a detailed medical history will be taken. The examination may include inspection of your nose with a delicate camera system. This is completely painless and allows us to show you what is going on inside your nose. If cosmetic nasal surgery is contemplated digital photographs will be taken to aid the analysis and allow for surgical planning. You will be able to see the likely outcome of surgery. If further tests are required (such as allergy testing or scans) these will be arranged and you will be seen again with the results. Very often these will be performed on the same day.

The diagnosis will then be discussed and a treatment plan tailored to your individual needs

Do I need a GP referral?


This is not absolutely necessary but Mr Mckiernan works closely with your own doctor and likes to keep them informed about your treatment

How much will it cost?


If your concerns are purely cosmetic Mr Mckiernan will generally see you for a nominal fee. However if there is a functional problem or you have recently suffered nasal trauma your medical insurance will cover your outpatient consultation. If surgery is required a written quotation will be sent to you , based on your individual treatment needs. In most cases we can offer a "Fixed Cost Care" fully inclusive package price for your operation and hospital stay. If you have any concerns please feel free to contact us.

If surgery is required how long will I need to take off work?


Providing you are otherwise healthy most nasal operations can be performed on a daycase basis (so that you could go home on the day of the surgery). The surgery is not painful but you will feel blocked up (like with a cold) for a week to ten days and your nose will run. If your job is physically demanding you will require two weeks off but if you wanted you would be able to undertake "deskwork" after two or three days.


Rhinosinusitis

Download PDF version
Introduction

Rhinosinusitis affects one in six people (17,18). It has a major impact on the patient's quality of life (19) and also has significant economic consequences. A conservative estimate of the cost of decreased productivity caused by allergic rhinitis or its treatment in North America is four billion dollars (20).

Definition

The term "rhinitis" implies a pathological diagnosis but the diagnosis is made clinically on the basis of the presence of two or more of the following symptoms for more than one hour on most days: sneezing, itching, rhinorrhoea and / or nasal obstruction (47). The nasal lining is continuous with that of the sinuses and so most patients with these symptoms have "rhinosinusitis".

Classification

The International Rhinitis Management Working Group in their consensus report agreed three main aetiological groups: Allergic, Infective and another group of heterogeneous conditions. More than one aetiology may affect the individual patient.

Allergic

This may be seasonal or perennial depending on the allergen involved. Seasonal allergic rhinitis due to grass pollens presents in May in the United Kingdom. Tree pollen allergy usually occurs earlier and weeds and moulds cause symptoms in summer and autumn. House dust mite and cat dander are the commonest causes of perennial allergic rhinitis.

Infective

This can be acute or chronic if symptoms persist beyond eight to twelve weeks. Acute rhinosinusitis is usually viral but when inflammation of the nasal lining impedes sinus ventilation / drainage through the region of the middle meatus (the so called ostiomeatal complex) secondary bacterial infection may develop.

Other:

1. Non-allergic, non-infective rhinosinusitis.

This group includes patients previously described as having intrinsic rhinitis, idiopathic rhinitis and vasomotor rhinitis. NARES (non-allergic rhinitis with eosinophilia) is also recognised (3). Some of these patients show a heightened sensitivity to non specific triggers such as humidity, air temperature and irritants and may complain of watery rhinorrhoea rather than blockage.

2. Rhinosinusitis with nasal polyps.

Nasal polyps can occur with cystic fibrosis (6,7) , asthma (8) and as part of a syndrome of aspirin sensitivity (9), but most commonly occur alone. The cause is unknown and while the prevalence of allergy is not higher in patients with polyps, mast cell reactions and eosinophil activation with subsequent inflammation seem to be implicated and explain why corticosteroids are therapeutically effective.

3. Endocrine

Pregnancy, puberty, hypothyroidism and acromegally are all associated with rhinosinusitis.

4. Rhinitis medicamentosa and drug - induced rhinitis

This condition may result from dependency on nasal decongestants. Beta blockers, NSAIDs and the oral contraceptive are other drugs commonly implicated.

5. Occupational rhinosinusitis

A variety of workplace chemicals - grain, wood-dusts and platinum salts for example - are known to cause a rhinosinusitis.

6. Atrophic rhinosinusitis

This is characterised by progressive atrophy of the sinonasal mucosa with viscid mucus which dries to fetid crusts. Klebsiella may be implicated but it may also result from over-aggressive surgery with removal of excessive mucosa , Sjogren's syndrome, ageing and SLE.

7. Food

Food can produce rhinosinusitis by a number of mechanisms (4). Gustatory rhinorrhoea (5) may occur when eating spicy foods. Specific allergic hypersensitivity reactions occur to particular foods ( or preservatives / colourants ) Alcohol produces a physiological vasodilatation and nasal congestion but can also provoke symptoms due to hypersensitivity. True food allergy is over-diagnosed and never causes isolated nasal symptoms.

8. Structural factors

Normal mucociliary clearance will be impaired where there is mucosal - mucosal contact - as in deviation of the nasal septum and concha bullosa and will result in neuropeptide mediated inflammation. These mechanical factors are amenable to corrective surgery and are classified by some authors as a separate major diagnostic group.

Differential Diagnosis.

When symptoms are unilateral one should be suspicious of malignancy. Where there is watery rhinorrhoea one should consider a cerebrospinal fluid leak, especially if unilateral. Lower respiratory tract pathology such as Wegener's and sarcoidosis may also be associated with nasal and sinus manifestations.

History.

Factors elicited in the history will help in determining the main aetiology. The chest and allergy deserve special attention. As well as eliciting specific nasal symptoms and their chronology, a thorough general medical history should be taken.

Examination.

Examination should include assessment of the external appearance of the nose and the anterior nasal septum to exclude structural deformities causing obstruction. Further assessment of the intranasal cavity may reveal polyps. Intranasal examination has been considerably enhanced with the advent of rigid and flexible endoscopes. The colour of the turbinates and mucus provide little diagnostic information.

Investigations

Immunological

1. Skin Prick Tests

Immediate hypersensitivity mediated by IgE can be demonstrated by skin-prick tests. They are preferred to scratch or intradermal tests which are less reproducible and more dangerous. However, the findings need careful interpretation in light of the clinical history as both false negative and false positive results occur (10) and there is little correlation between weal or flare size and symptoms (11). The majority of patients with allergic rhinitis are sensitive to a relatively small range of aeroallergens. A positive skin-prick test provides supportive evidence for the clinical diagnosis and is reassuring where costly or time-consuming allergen avoidance measures are suggested. It also re-inforces patient understanding.

2. Serum Specific IgE

When there is no extract for skin-prick testing, or skin-prick testing is not possible because of skin disease or the patient is on antihistamines specific serum IgE measurements can be made. (Radioallergosorbent-RAST test)

Radiological

1. Plain Sinus Films

Plain radiographs have a limited role in the management of rhinosinusitis because they have such poor specificity and sensitivity (12). A positive finding of a fluid level in acute sinusitis may be helpful.

2. CT scans

CT scans provide important anatomical information if surgery is contemplated and demonstrate the extent of disease. There are false positives (48) but a clear scan is useful in excluding chronic sinonasal disease.

Bacteriology

Guarded specimens obtained under direct endoscopic visualisation of the middle meatus correlate well with formal sinus aspirates, in contrast to blind nasal swabs.

Other Investigations

In the specialist and research setting further investigations may help to determine a complex aetiology and assess treatment outcome. These include assessments of ciliary function, olfaction, and the nasal airway.

Treatment (After International Rhinitis Management Working Group)

1. Seasonal Allergic Rhinosinusitis

Allergen avoidance

Some allergens eg pollen are ubiquitous and avoidance is not always possible. However measures can be taken to minimise exposure. In the case of house-dust mite sensitivity these would include synthetic bedding and mattress covers, removing soft furnishings and carpet from the bedroom, and regular vacuuming.

Mild disease or occasional symptoms

Rapid onset oral non-sedating antihistamines or topical antihistamines or cromoglycate drops are recommended when symptomatic.

Moderate disease

A recent meta analysis of sixteen randomised controlled trials comparing intranasal corticosteroids and H1 receptor antagonists in the treatment of allergic rhinitis(21) suggests that intranasal corticosteroids are superior to antihistamines in treating the nasal symptoms of allergic rhinitis and (22), as effective as antihistamines in treating the eye symptoms.

If above inaffective refer for:

-nasal examination
-allergy testing
-systemmic steroids or betnesol
-consideration of immunotherapy

Perennial Allergic Rhinosinusitis in Adults


Allergen avoidance
Topical nasal steroid if long term exposure
Oral non-sedating antihistamines (and possibly oral decongestant) in intermittent disease.

Perennial Allergic Rhinosinusitis in Children

Allergen avoidance
Topical nasal sodium cromoglycate spray
Oral non-sedating antihistamine
Topical nasal steroid if above ineffective or if long-term exposure

2. Perennial Non-Allergic Rhinosinusitis

With little watery discharge Avoidance of irritants and advice to stop smoking Topical nasal steroid sprays (if effective may be needed long-term)

If treatment ineffective after one month:
- consider betnesol drops for six weeks or short course of systemmic steroids
- oral decongestants
- referral to specialist
- With copious watery discharge Avoidance of irritants and advice to stop smoking Topical nasal anticholinergic

Pharmacology

Antihistamines

Antihistamines act as competitive antagonists at the histamine receptor. They are effective in reducing established symptoms of sneezing, itching and watery rhinorrhoea in particular. Cetirizine, loratidine, acrivastine and terfenadine suppress skin reactions for about four days after drug ingestion whereas astemizole has a much longer half-life and reduces skin prick reactions for up to eight weeks (23). Cetirizine is unique in that it is not metabolised in the liver but excreted in the urine.

Reports (24,25) have associated astemizole and terfenadine with serious cardiac arrhythmias. This is because in high doses the delayed rectifier potassium channels are blocked prolonging the QT interval (26). The drugs are metabolised in the liver by the cytochrome P450 system and should therefore not be used in hepatic failure or together with competitors for the P450 system ( such as macrolide antibiotics and antifungals ). Fexofenadine, the active metabolite of terfenadine is free of this arrhythmogenic effect.

Though controversial it is likely that antihistamines exert an anti-inflammatory effect beyond that produced solely by antagonism of the H1 receptor. Certainly the production of adhesion molecules (ICAM-1), and the release of interleukin- 8 ( a neutrophil chemotactic and activating factor ) and granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor from epithelial cells stimulated by activated eosinophils is reduced (27).

Comparitive studies between oral antihistamines are difficult to evaluate. Full dose-response curves have not been performed in the same individuals to compare efficacy and side effects. However the greater cost of the non-sedating antihistamines is substantially offset by the lack of effect on performance.

Topical antihistamines such as azelastine and levocabastine are available and can be used for acute symptomatic relief and prophylaxis of allergic rhinitis without systemic side effects.

Corticosteroids

Corticosteroids penetrate the cell membrane and bind to hormone receptors in the cytoplasm. Within the nucleus the steroid/receptor complex binds to specific DNA sites which have a regulatory role in protein synthesis. This is manifest in a reduction in inflammatory cell infiltration and its consequences (29).

Corticosteroids may be given topically, taken orally or adminstered intravenously.

Topical corticosteroids are effective in reducing nasal blockage, itching, sneezing and rhinorrhoea in allergic and non-allergic non-infective rhinosinusitis (34). Their ability to reduce nasal blockage and efficacy in non-allergic rhinitis gives them an advantage over antihistamines. They are more effective in symptomatic control of allergic rhinitis than sodium cromoglycate (35), antihistamines (36) and decongestants (37).

Numerous comparative studies have been performed but there are no published studies that show one nasal steroid is more effective than any other (eg 53,54,55). Therefore, choice of agent depends on patient preference and cost.

Beclomethasone was introduced in 1973 and combined high topical efficacy with rapid hepatic metabolism (28). Subsequently a variety of topical nasal steroid sprays have become available. These are: budesonide (rhinocort), flunisolide (syntaris), fluticasone (flixonase), mometasone (nasonex) and triamcinolone (nasocort). With the exception of beclomethasone and flunisolide they are once-a-day preparations.

Environmental concerns have led to the elimination of CFC driven aerosols. Topical corticosteroids are therefore administered by mechanical pump sprays in aqueous or glycol solutions or as a dry powder. There has been some concern that benzalkonium chloride, a preservative used in intranasal corticosteroid sprays, has toxic effects on cultured nasal epithelium (48) but this effect has not been demonstrated in vivo (49).

Of greater concern is the extent of systemic absorption and the effects on growth in children. Although there are few studies into the effects of topical nasal steroids there have been numerous ones into the effects of inhaled and oral steroids on growth. A meta-analysis performed in 1994 (30) indicates that while oral steroids do indeed reduce final height, the use of inhaled beclomethasone diproprionate does not appear to be associated with diminished stature even at twice the normal dose. However in a randomised double blind crossover study of 19 schoolchildren with mild asthma, treated by inhaled steroids, compared with fluticasone, use of beclamethasone was associated with a statistically significant reduction in lower leg growth velocity (38). The Committee on Safety of medicines and the Medicines Control Agency have concluded (50) that "clinically important systemic adverse effects occur at licensed doses" but in mitigation state: "It is important to emphasise that inhaled ... corticosteroids provide proven, effective control of ... rhinitis ... and may in some patients remove the necessity for oral corticosteroid therapy. The recognition that systemic effects may occur, and that the lowest effective dose should be used, does not alter the favourable risk-benefit profile of these medicines". Topical nasal steroids are not recommended under the age of four.

Short courses of oral steroid can be used, perhaps immediately prior to or following surgery, but only with caution. Contraindications to treatment with systemic steroids include diabetes mellitus, gastric ulceration, osteoporosis, severe hypertension and herpes keratitis or other severe infection. Betamethasone sodium phosphate drops are also very effective in symptomatic relief of allergic and non-allergic non-infectious rhinosinusitis. They are however capable of producing minor systemic steroid effects so their longterm use cannot be recommended. Two drops of betamethasone to each nostril twice daily has been estimated to be equivalent to 1.15mg prednisolone daily (31). Proper drop insertion technique is crucial. Radiological studies and clinical evidence support the "head down and forwards technique" (32,33).

Sodium Cromoglycate

Sodium cromoglycate was first synthesised in 1965 and noted to cause a novel inhibition of degranulation of rat peritoneal mast cells (39). This gave rise to the concept of mast cell "stabilisation". Although this action has been demonstrated in in-vitro studies of human lung mast cells and mast cells recovered by bronchoalveolar lavage (40), this mechanism does not seem to apply in mast cells recovered from nasal scrapings in rhinitis (41). Instead the effectiveness of the drug in this setting is attributed to its ability to influence granulocyte chemotaxis (42) and reduce endothelial adhesion molecule expression (43).

Sodium cromoglycate reduces nasal itching, sneezing, rhinorrhoea and blockage in allergic rhinitis. It has negligible side effects (burning sensation) but needs to be applied four times a day. It is primarily a prophylactic drug for use in children but is less effective than topical corticosteroids.

Anticholinergics

Cholinergic receptors are important in the production of nasal secretions but have no affect on nasal blockage, itching or sneezing (44). Ipratropium bromide is therefore useful in the treatment of patients with profuse rhinorrhoea but can cause local drying of the nasal mucosa which is minimised by allowing the patient to decide on the lowest effective dose (45).

Decongestants

The nasal administration of local vasoconstrictors is not usually recommended for more than 3-4 weeks because of the risk of rhinitis medicamentosa (51). However, used prior to other treatments for short periods they can be a useful adjunct to therapy.

Future Developments

As the mechanisms of rhinitis are elucidated and the roles of specific inflammatory mediators clarified new therapeutic strategies suggest themselves. For example leukotrienne receptor antagonists may prove helpful for aspirin sensitive patients who produce excessive leukotriennes and exhibit increased sensitivity to them Immunotherapy The efficacy of desensitisation is well documented in double blind controlled trials but can cause life-threatening reactions, especially in asthmatics. For this reason the practice has been significantly curtailed and in the UK asthmatics are specifically excluded from this treatment. Patients should only be desensitised by suitably trained physicians with adrenaline immediately available (46).

Specific immunotherapy is appropriate where pharmacotherapy inadequately controls the symptoms of allergic rhinitis or the side-affects are unacceptable or appropriate avoidance measures fail. There should be at least a six month history in perennial rhinitis or two season history in allergic rhinitis and positive skin tests or serum specific IgE which correlate with the symptoms.

Surgery (FESS)


Surgery should be reserved for patients in whom medical treatment has failed.
When medical treatment has failed , numerous studies have found that surgery benefits at least 80% of patients. When surgery is indicated it should be directed at removing diseased mucosa ( including nasal polyps) and mucosal contact areas. This will help to drain the sinuses and allow aeration, facilitate the recovery of cilia and allow access for topical nasal medication.
Whilst surgery provides good symptomatic relief continued medical treatment and further surgery are often required.
Endoscopic surgery has the advantage that no external incision is required
Surgical procedures on the internal and external nasal structures to correct mechanical obstruction of the airway results in improvement in subjective nasal symptoms as well as objective measurements.

References.


3. Jacobs R L, Fredman I M,Boswell R N. Non-allergic rhinitis with eosinophilia (NARES syndrome): clinical and immunological presentation. J Allergy Clin Immun1981: 67: 253-62.

4. Metcalfe D D. The diagnosis of food allergy: theory and practice. In Spector S, ed. Provocative challenge procedures: bronchial, oral, nasal and exercise. Vol 2. Boca Raton: CRC Press, 1983: 119-25.

5. Raphael G D, Hauptschein-Raphael M,Kaliner M. Gustatory rhinitis: a syndrome of food-induced rhinorrhoea. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1989: 83: 110-15.

6. Stern R C,Boat T F, Wood R E. Treatment and prognosis of nasal polyps in cystic fibrosis. Am J Dis Child1982: 136: 1067-70.

7. Disant Agnese P A, David P B. Cystic fibrosis in adults: 75 cases and areview of 232 cases in the literature. Am J Med 1979: 66: 121-32.

8. Drake-Lee A B, Lowe D, Swanston A, Grace A. Clinical profile and recurrence of nasal polyps. J Laryngol Otol 1984: 98: 783-93.

9. Harnett J C, Spector S L, Farr R S. Aspirin idiosyncracy, asthma and urticaria. In: Middleton E, Reed C E, Ellis E F, eds. Allergy: principles and practice. St Louis: C V Mosby, 1978: 1002-21.

10. Sampson H A. Comparitive study of commercial food antigen extracts for the diagnosis of food hypersensitivity. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1988; 82: 718-26.

11. van der Linden P G, Hack C E, Struyvenberg A, van der Zwan J K. Insect-sting challenge in 324 subjects with a previous anaphylactic reaction: current criteria do not predict the occurrence and severity of anaphylaxis. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1994; 94: 151-9.

12. The Royal College of Radiologists. Making the best use of a Department of Clinical Radiology. Third Edition. 1995. The Royal College of Radiologists. London. 1-96. ISBN: 1 872599 04 4.

17. Scadding G K. Nasal Symptoms. Update. 1997. March 268-276.

18. Sibbald B, Rink E. Epidemiology of seasonal and perennial Rhinitis: clinical presentation and medical history. Thorax. 1991. 46,895-901. 19. Juniper E F, Guyatt G H. Development and testing of a new measure of health statusfor clinical trials in rhinoconjunctivitis.

20. Fireman P. Treatment of allergic rhinitis: Effect on occupation productivity and work force costs. Allergy and Asthma Proc. 1997. 18 (2) 63-67.

21. Weiner M J, Abramson M J, Puy R M. Intranasal corticosteroids versus oral H1 receptor antagonists in allergic rhinitis: systematic review of randomised control trials. BMJ 1998: 317: 1624-1629.

22. Calderon-Zapata M A, Davies R J. Treatment and management of allergic rhinitis. In: Kay A B, ed. Allergy and allergic diseases. Oxford: Blackwell, 1997.

23. Felderman R B, Rosen L J. Comparison of the onset and offset of inhibition of antigen induced skin whealing of terfenadine, astemizole and placebo. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1987: 79: 190-4.

24. Craft T M. Torsade de pointes after astemizole overdose. BMJ 1986;292: 660.

25. Monahan B P et al. Torsade de pointes occuring in association with terfenadine use. JAMA 1991;266: 2375-6.

26. Rampe D et al. Effects of terfenadine and its metabolites on a delayed rectifier K+ channel cloned from the human heart. Mol Pharmacol 1993;44: 1240-5.

27. Abdelaziz M M et al. Effect of fexofenadine on eosinophil induced changes in epithelial permeability and mediator release from nasal epithelial cells of seasonal allergic rhinitics. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1997

28. Mygind N. Local effect of intranasal beclomethasone diproprionate aerosol in hay fever. BMJ 1973: 4: 464-6.

29. Minshall E, Ghaffar O, Cameron L, O`Brien F, Quinn H, Rowe-Jones J, Davies R J, Prior A, Lund V J, Mackay I S, Nolop K, Lutsky B, Durham S R, Hamid Q. Assessment by nasal biopsy of long-term use of mometasone aqueous nasal spray in the treatment of perennial rhinitis. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1998; 118: 648-54.

30. Allen D B, Mullen M, mullen B. 1994. A meta-analysis of the effect of oral and inhaled corticosteroids on growth. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1994; 93(6): 967-76

31. Mackay I. ed. (1989) Topical medical management of allergic conditions of the nose. Part 2: Intranasal steroids. In: Rhinitis . Mechanisms and management. London: Royal Society of Medicine Services Limited. pp183-204

32. Charlton R, Mackay I, Wilson R, Cole P. Double-blind placebo controlled trial of betamethasone nasal drops for nasal polyposis. BMJ 1985; 291: 788.

33. Wilson R, Sykes D, Chan K, Cole P, Mackay I. The effect of head position on the efficacy of topical treatment of chronic mucopurulent rhinosinusitis. Thorax 1987; 42: 631-2

34. Orgel H A, Meltzer E O, Bierman W et al. Intranasal fluocortin butyl in patients with perennial rhinitis: a 12-month efficacy and safety study including nasal biopsy. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1991:88: 257-64.

35. Welsh P W, Stricker W E, Chu-Pin C, et al. Efficacy of beclomethasone nasal solution, flunisolide and cromlyn in relieving symptoms in ragweed allergy. May Clin Proc 1987: 62: 125-34.

36. Harding S M, Heath S. Intranasal steroid aerosol in perennial rhinitis: comparison with antihistamine compound. Clin Allergy 1976: 6: 369-72.

37. Juniper E F, Kline P A, Hargreave F E, Dolovich J. Comparison of beclomethasone diproprionate aqueous nasal spray, astemizole and the combination in prophylactic treatment of ragweed pollen-induced rhinoconjunctivitis. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1989: 83: 627-33.

38. Wolthers O D, Pederson S. Short-term growth during treatment with inhaled fluticasone proprionate and beclomethasone diproprionate. Arch Dis Child. 1993: 68(5): 673-6.

39. Cos J. Disodium cromoglycate (FPL 670 "intal") : a specific inhibitor of reaginic antigen-antibody mechanisms. Nature (London) 1967; 216: 1328-9.

40. Pearce F L, Al_Laith M, Bosman L, et al. Effects of sodium cromoglycate and nedocromil sodium on histamine secretion from various locations. Drugs 1989; 37 (suppl): 37-43.

41. Okuda M, Ohnishi M, Ohtsuka H. The effect of cromolyn sodium on the nasal mast cells. Ann Allergy 1985; 55: 721-3.

42. Kay A B, Walsh G M, Moqbel R, et al. Disodium cromoglycate inhibits activation of human inflammatory cells in vitro. J Allergy Clin Immunol.1987; 80: 1-8.

43. Klein L M, Larker R M, Matis W L, Murphy G F. Degranulation of human mast cells induces an endothelial antigen central to leucocyte adhesion. Proc Natl Acad Sci 1989; 86: 8972-6.

44. Borum P, Mugind N, Schultz Larsen F. Intranasal ipratropium: a new treatment for perennial rhinitis. Clin Otolaryngol 1979; 4: 407-11.

45. Dolovich J, Kennedy L, Vickerson F, Kazim F. Control of the hypersecretion of vasomotor rhinitis by topical ipratropium bromide. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1987; 80: 274-8.

46. Malling H J, Weeke B. EAACI Position Paper. Immunotherapy. Allergy 1993: 48 (suppl. 14): 1-35.

47. International Rhinitis Management Working Group. International Consensus Report on the Diagnosis and management of Rhinitis. Allergy 1994: 49 (supp. 19): 1-30.

48. Steinsvag S K, Bjerknes R, Berg O H. Effects on human respiratory mucosa and human granulocytes of decongestive nosedrops and topical nasal steroids in vitro. Abstract-book EAACI. Rotterdam 1993: 22 (no. 1083).

49. Braat J P M, Ainge G, Bowles J A K, Richards D H, van Riessen D, Visser W J and Rijntjes E. The lack of effect of benzalkonium chloride on the cilia of the nasal mucosa in patients with perennial allergic rhinitis: a combined functional, light, scanning and transmission electron microscopy study. Clinical and Experimental Allergy 1995: 25: 957-65.

50. Current Problems in Pharmacovigilance, Focus on Corticosteroids. May 1998: 24: 5-10.

51. Yoo J K, Seikaly H, Calhoun K H. Extended use of topical nasal decongestant. Laryngoscope. 1997 107 (1): 40-43.

52. Statements of Clinical Effectiveness in Otolaryngology 1998. British Association of Otolaryngologists Head and neck Surgeons.

53. Scadding G K, Lund V J, Jacques L A and Richards D H. A placebo controlled study of fluticasone proprionate aqueous nasal spray and beclomethasone diproprionate in perennial rhinitis: efficacy in allergic and non-allergic perennial rhinitis. Clinical and Experimental Allergy, 1995, Volume 25, 737-43.

54. Mandl M, Nolop K and Lutsky B. Comparison of once daily mometasone furoate and fluticasone proprionate aqueous nasal sprays for the treatment of perennial rhinitis. Annals of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology. Oct 1997, volume 79, No 4, 370-8.

55. Haye R, Gomez E. A multicentre study to assess long-term use of fluticasone proprionate aqueous nasal spray in comparison with beclomethasone diproprionate aqueous nasal spray in the treatment of perennial rhinitis. Rhinology. 1993. 31,169-74.

Patient information leaflets

Appointments


Mr Mckiernan consults at the following private hospitals:

The Cambridge Nuffield Hospital
4 Trumpington Road
Cambridge
CB2 2AA
Tel: 01223 303336
www.nuffieldhospitals.org.uk

BMI St Edmund's Hospital
St Mary's Square
Bury St Edmunds
IP33 2AA
Tel: 01284 701371
www.bmihealthcare.co.uk

The Rivers Hospital
High Wych Road, Sawbridgeworth
Herts
CM21 OHH
Tel: 01279 602675
www.ramsayhealth.co.uk

The Spire Cambridge Lea
30 New Road
Impington
Cambridge
CB24 9EL
Tel: 01223 266990
www.spirehealth.com

and sees NHS patients in the following hospitals:

Addenbrooke's Hospital NHS Trust
Hills Road
Cambridge
CB2 2QQ

Tel: 01223 257230

West Suffolk Hospital NHS Trust
Hardwick Lane
Bury St Edmunds
IP33 2QZ

Tel: 01284 713820

 


Private Secretary: Sue Tarry

Tel: 01954 780588
Fax: 01954 781952
appointments@nose.org.uk



 
 
Copyright Mr D C Mckiernan FRCS